Skip to main content

Table 5 The adjusted effect models

From: Impact of interventions on the quality of life of cancer patients: a systematic review and meta-analysis of longitudinal research

 

n

%

Model 1

Health utility scale

Model 2

Types of cancer

Model 3

Types of interventions

Model 4

Country types

Model 5

Study designs

Coeff. (95% CI)

Coeff. (95% CI)

Coeff. (95% CI)

Coeff. (95% CI)

Coeff. (95% CI)

Const

  

47.519***

43.481***

34.610***

47.339***

47.447***

(21.051–73.987)

(20.399–66.563)

(10.496–58.724)

(20.998–73.681)

(20.861–74.033)

Measure

 EORTC

3141

65.15

0.184

-1.610

4.285

0.040

-0.921

(-26.512–26.881)

(-26.576–23.356)

(-19.078–27.648)

(-26.512–26.591)

(-27.934–26.092)

 FACT

584

12.11

-2.111

-6.564

1.557

-2.293

-3.578

(-31.500–27.279)

(-32.908–19.779)

(-23.929–27.042)

(-31.891–27.305)

(-33.276–26.119)

 SF36

466

9.67

27.583

16.859

30.574*

26.836

24.989

(-8.753–63.918)

(-14.484–48.203)

(-0.489–61.636)

(-9.600–63.271)

(-12.163–62.141)

 QLI

59

1.22

-4.078

-2.128

-2.855

-4.236

-5.215

(-34.823–26.667)

(-33.027–28.772)

(-30.749–25.040)

(-34.783–26.311)

(-35.977–25.548)

 FLIC

55

1.14

31.146

23.858

41.435*

30.254

29.797

(-20.313–82.605)

(-26.729–74.445)

(-6.886–89.757)

(-20.421–80.928)

(-20.825–80.419)

 VAS

23

0.48

-43.518**

-46.011**

-41.824**

-43.561**

-43.851**

(-79.783 - -7.252)

(-83.782 - -8.239)

(-76.787 - -6.862)

(-79.765 - -7.358)

(-80.270 - -7.432)

 Other

456

9.46

-24.614*

-29.579**

-21.882*

-25.147*

-25.409*

(-50.459–1.231)

(-52.579 - -6.580)

(-44.499–0.735)

(-50.800–0.506)

(-51.439–0.620)

Types of cancer

 Breast cancer

787

16.32

 

6.310

   
 

(-7.831–20.451)

   

 Head and Neck cancer

688

14.27

 

-0.615

   
 

(-13.797–12.567)

   

 Research evaluating more than one type of cancer

540

11.20

 

5.158

   
 

(-6.084–16.400)

   

 Prostate cancer

406

8.42

 

26.599***

   
 

(12.554–40.643)

   

 Esophageal or gastroesophageal junction cancer

230

4.77

 

16.410***

   
 

(5.891–26.928)

   

 Ovarian cancer

135

2.80

 

10.208

   
 

(-18.694–39.109)

   

 Gastric cancer

122

2.53

 

27.848*

   
 

(-3.809–59.505)

   

 Gastrointestinal cancer

119

2.47

 

-4.927

   
 

(-13.258–3.404)

   

 Endometrial Cancer

114

2.36

 

-5.708

   
 

(-18.357–6.942)

   

 Nasopharyngeal carcinoma

90

1.87

 

4.845

   
 

(-5.746–15.436)

   

 Esophageal cancer

84

1.74

 

16.134

   
 

(-18.555–50.822)

   

 Cervical cancer

80

1.66

 

-18.021***

   
 

(-28.612 - -7.430)

   

 Leukemia

77

1.60

 

26.837*

   
 

(-3.725–57.398)

   

 Gynecological Cancer

73

1.51

 

14.543

   
 

(-8.913–37.998)

   

 Colorectal cancer

71

1.47

 

20.009***

   
 

(9.418–30.600)

   

 Pancreatic cancer

60

1.24

 

-0.251

   
 

(-10.842–10.340)

   

 laryngeal cancer

58

1.20

 

5.969

   
 

(-10.065–22.003)

   

 Sarcoma

57

1.18

 

-6.667

   
 

(-17.258–3.924)

   

 Malignant Melanoma

54

1.12

 

-17.089

   
 

(-49.960–15.782)

   

 Rectal cancer

53

1.10

 

-8.052

   
 

(-18.643–2.539)

   

 Hodgkin Lymphoma

42

0.87

 

29.844***

   
 

(19.253–40.435)

   

 Eye cancer

30

0.62

 

6.765

   
 

(-3.826–17.356)

   

 Rectal cell cancer

30

0.62

 

-0.208

   
 

(-10.799–10.383)

   

 Carcinoma

28

0.58

 

-4.324

   
 

(-14.915–6.267)

   

 Brain cancer

18

0.37

 

41.822***

   
 

(33.388–50.257)

   

 Bone cancer

6

0.12

 

6.672

   
 

(-13.840–27.184)

   

 Acute myeloid leukemia

2

0.04

 

95.083***

   
 

(81.332–108.835)

   

 Kidney cancer

2

0.04

 

-43.241***

   
 

(-66.323 - -20.159)

   

Types of interventions

 Chemotherapy + Radiotherapy

623

12.92

  

0.703

  
  

(-13.855–15.260)

  

 Psychological support program

611

12.67

  

4.729

  
  

(-8.024–17.482)

  

 Radiotherapy

368

7.63

  

30.588***

  
  

(17.327–43.850)

  

 Palliative care

336

6.97

  

18.355**

  
  

(3.308–33.403)

  

 Chemotherapy + Radiotherapy + Surgery

255

5.29

  

-0.395

  
  

(-11.495–10.705)

  

 Radiotherapy + surgery

250

5.19

  

-6.789

  
  

(-26.329–12.750)

  

 Physical exercise

236

4.90

  

13.728**

  
  

(0.180–27.275)

  

 Combine curative and palliative care

218

4.52

  

23.787**

  
  

(2.813–44.762)

  

 Chemotherapy + surgery

182

3.78

  

4.846

  
  

(-4.855–14.548)

  

 Psychological group therapy

165

3.42

  

-3.831

  
  

(-12.328–4.666)

  

 Short term psycho-educational

110

2.28

  

-0.648

  
  

(-9.118–7.823)

  

 Stem Cell Transplantation

80

1.66

  

4.324

  
  

(-15.740–24.388)

  

 Complementary Alternative therapy

66

1.37

  

5.050

  
  

(-5.189–15.290)

  

 Best supportive care + chemotherapy

60

1.24

  

59.782***

  
  

(48.743–70.820)

  

 Screening

51

1.06

  

31.006***

  
  

(18.284–43.729)

  

 Anti-hormone Therapy

48

1.00

  

-2.414

  
  

(-17.791–12.962)

  

Country type

 Upper middle-income country

484

10.04

   

3.645

 
   

(-9.238–16.528)

 

Study design

 Randomized control trials

1410

29.25

    

2.321

    

(-7.952–12.593)

 Cohort study

687

14.25

    

4.912

    

(-4.602–14.426)

 Case-control study

256

5.31

    

9.143

    

(-19.333–37.619)

  1. Robust ci in parentheses
  2. *** p < 0.01, ** p < 0.05, * p < 0.1