Skip to main content

Table 3 Results of distribution and anchor based approaches (N = 46)

From: Distribution- and anchor-based methods to determine the minimally important difference on patient-reported outcome questionnaires in oncology: a structured review

 

Number

Percent

Distribution-based approach (N = 40)

 Distribution-reported

  0.2 SD at baseline

12

30

  0.3 SD at baseline

25

62.5

  0.5 SD at baseline

36

90

  SEM at baseline

31

77.5

  0.2 SD at follow-up

7

17.5

  0.3 SD at follow-up

14

35

  0.5 SD at follow-up

14

35

  SEM at follow-up

13

32.5

  0.2 SD of change

2

5

  0.3 SD of change

8

20

  0.5 SD of change

7

17.5

  SEM of change

5

12.5

Anchor-based approach (N = 43)

 Study design

  Cross-sectional

3

7.1

  Longitudinal design

39

92.9

 Number of anchors

  1

23

53.5

  2

8

18.6

  3

3

7

  4

3

7

   ≥ 5

6

13.9

 Anchors

  Overall rating of change

9

20.93

  Anchor derived from an external questionnaire

13

30.2

  Anchor derived from one dimension of the questionnaire studied

8

18.6

  Performance status

15

34.9

  MMSE

1

2.3

  Weight loss

1

2.3

  Other

10

23.3

 Correlation checked between anchor and the studied questionnaire

  Yes

32

76.2

  No

9

21.4

Criteria used to detect a moderate correlation (N = 32)

   ≥ 0.3

15

46.9

   ≥ 0.4

1

3.1

   ≥ 0.5

1

3.1

  Not reported

15

46.9

 Minimum N by anchor category

   ≤ 20

16

37.2

   > 20

18

41.9

  Not reported

9

20.9

  1. SD standard deviation, SEM standard error of measurement, MMSE mini mental state examination