Skip to main content

Table 10 Results of studies assessing internal consistency of the instruments included in the review

From: Measuring carer quality of life in Duchenne muscular dystrophy: a systematic review of the reliability and validity of self-report instruments using COSMIN

Instrument

N (DMD subsample)

Mean (SD) Age (DMD subsample)

% Female (DMD subsample)

Country

Cronbach’s α

Rating of measurement property

Rating

Quality of evidence

CWBS [35]

60

NR

41.7

India

0.92

+

Moderate

DUKE [37]

126

43 (6.1)

57.4

Taiwan

0.81

+

High

FAPGAR [37]

126

43 (6.1)

57.4

Taiwan

0.89

+

High

FPQ [46]a

336 (246 DMD)

41.2 (6.2) for DMD carers

84.2 (83.3 DMD)

Italy

Ranged from 0.66 to 0.87

?

High

HADS (Anxiety) [32]

82 (71 DMD)

40.40 (6.98)

100

USA

0.87

+

Moderate

HADS (Depression) [32]

82 (71 DMD)

40.40 (6.98)

100

USA

0.8

+

Moderate

PAS [51]

205 at baseline (147 at year 1, 144 at year 2)

44 (8.7)

100

USA

0.96

+

High

PPC [51]

205 at baseline (147 at year 1, 144 at year 2)

44 (8.7)

100

USA

0.79

+

High

PSS [32]

82 (71 DMD)

40.40 (6.98)

100

USA

0.89

+

Moderate

QRS [53]

36

43.04 (5.52)

69.44

Canada

0.86

+

Low

SF-36 [32]a

82 (71 DMD)

40.40 (6.98)

100

USA

Ranged from 0.76 to 0.88

+

Moderate

SNQ (subscale A) [46]

336 (246 DMD)

41.2 (6.2) for DMD carers

84.2 (83.3 DMD)

Italy

0.69

High

WAC-DBMD [51]

205 at baseline (147 at year 1, 144 at year 2)

44 (8.7)

100

USA

0.89

+

High

ZBI (22 item) [60]

475

44 (NR)

81

UK, US

0.914

+

High

ZBI (12 item) [51]

205 at baseline (147 at year 1, 144 at year 2)

44 (8.7)

100

USA

0.89

+

High

  1. Citation next to the instrument is for the study assessing this measurement property
  2. NR, not reported
  3. aFPQ and SF-36 subscales were assessed separately, however Cronbach’s α was reported as a range across all scales