Depression change | Mean SRM | CAMEO | SPACE | SSM | |||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Score change* | SRM†| (95% CI) | P‡ | Score change* | SRM†| (95% CI) | P‡ | Score change* | SRM†| (95% CI) | P‡ | ||
PROMIS 4-item |  |  |  |  | .008 |  |  |  |  < .0001 |  |  |  |  < .0001 |
 Better | .54 | 3.58 | .48 | (.23, .75) | .019 | 5.12 | .59 | (.38, .81) |  < .0001 | 4.81 | .56 | (.32, .82) | .005 |
 Same | .10 | − 0.17 | − .02 | (− .27, .25) | – |  − 0.14 | − .02 | (− .21, .17) | – | 1.41 | .27 | (.10, .44) | – |
 Worse | − .27 | − 1.09 | − .12 | (− .55, .32) | .87 |  − 3.38 | − .55 | (− .95, − .19) | .122 | − 1.55 | − .16 |  | .072 |
PROMIS 6-item |  |  |  |  | .008 |  |  |  |  < .0001 |  |  |  |  < .0001 |
 Better | .58 | 4.13 | .54 | (.29, .80) | .039 | 5.85 | .64 | (.42, .87) |  < .0001 | 5.17 | .55 | (.33, .79) | .003 |
 Same | .13 | 0.72 | .13 | (− .14, .41) | – | 0.16 | .03 | (− .16, .21) | – | 1.35 | .23 | (.06, .41) | – |
 Worse | − .28 | − 1.03 | − .11 | (− .54, .33) | .61 |  − 2.95 | − .52 | (− .94, − .12) | .186 | − 1.94 | − .21 | (− .53, .12) | .055 |
PROMIS 8-item |  |  |  |  | .007 |  |  |  | < .0001 |  |  |  | < .0001 |
 Better | .59 | 4.22 | .56 | (.31, .83) | .037 | 5.93 | .65 | (.43, .88) | < .0001 | 5.16 | .55 | (.33, .79) | .002 |
 Same | .14 | 0.76 | .13 | (− .13, .39) | – | 0.19 | .03 | (− .15, .21) | – | 1.39 | .26 | (.09, .44) | – |
 Worse | − .27 | − 1.00 | − .11 | (− .54, .34) | .61 | − 3.12 | − .53 | (− .95, − .14) | .141 | − 1.56 | − .17 | (− .48, .16) | .082 |
PROMIS SF |  |  |  |  | .009 |  |  |  | < .0001 |  |  |  | < .0001 |
 Better | .60 | 4.22 | .56 | (.31, .84) | .077 | 6.51 | .70 | (.47, .95) | < .0001 | 5.26 | .54 | (.31, .79) | .003 |
 Same | .16 | 1.10 | .17 | (− .09, .44) | – | 0.45 | .08 | (− .11, .26) | – | 1.33 | .22 | (.05, .39) | – |
 Worse | − .33 | − 1.35 | − .14 | (− .58, .30) | .40 | − 3.57 | − .65 | (− 1.2, − .19) | .060 | − 1.94 | − .20 | (− .51, .12) | .068 |
PROMIS average | Â | Â | Â | Â | Â | Â | Â | Â | Â | Â | Â | Â | Â |
 Better | .58 |  | .54 |  |  |  | .65 |  |  |  | .55 |  |  |
 Same | .13 |  | .10 |  |  |  | .03 |  |  |  | .25 |  |  |
 Worse | − .29 |  | − .12 |  |  |  | − .56 |  |  |  | − .19 |  |  |
PHQ-9 |  |  |  |  | .002 |  |  |  | < .0001 |  |  |  | .001 |
 Better | .63 | 3.56 | .71 | (.43, 1.0) | .026 | 2.52 | .67 | (.48, .87) | .002 | 3.23 | .51 | (.27, .76) | .014 |
 Same | .24 | 1.07 | .25 | (− .02, .56) | – | 0.69 | .20 | (.02, .40) | – | 1.13 | .26 | (.09, .43) | – |
 Worse | − .18 | − 0.73 | − .13 | (− .60, .31) | .34 | − 1.45 | − .33 | (− .84, .10) | .039 | − 0.30 | − .07 | (− .42, .26) | .28 |
PHQ-2 |  |  |  |  | .163 |  |  |  |  < .0001 |  |  |  | .007 |
 Better | .53 | 0.78 | .50 | (.25, .75) | .44 | 0.93 | .71 | (.53, .89) |  < .0001 | 0.81 | .39 | (.14, .66) | .045 |
 Same | .16 | 0.39 | .25 | (.− .01, .51) | – | 0.12 | .11 | (− .08, .33) | – | 0.19 | .13 | (− .04, .30) | – |
 Worse | − .24 | 0.00 | − .01 | (− .49, .41) | .63 | − 0.48 | − .33 | (− .97, .14) | .143 | − 0.24 | − .12 | (− .42, .22) | .38 |
SF-36 Mental |  |  |  |  |  < .0001 |  |  |  |  |  |  |  |  |
 Better |  | 15.18 | .71 | (.50, .94) |  < .0001 |  |  |  |  |  |  |  |  |
 Same |  | − 0.22 | − .02 | (− .28, .25) | – |  |  |  |  |  |  |  |  |
 Worse |  |  − 9.55 | − .69 | (− 1.5, − .17) | .076 |  |  |  |  |  |  |  |  |