Skip to main content

Table 1 Eligibility criteria for quantitative and qualitative studies

From: Informing the measurement of wellbeing among young people living with HIV in sub-Saharan Africa for policy evaluations: a mixed-methods systematic review

 

Inclusion

Exclusion

Quantitative studies

Population

• Young people living with HIV (aged 15–24 years)

• Studies were < 50% of the population is between the ages of 15–24 years

• Studies that focus on specific population groups (i.e. orphans, LGBTQI, pregnant or post-partum women, sex workers, homeless youth, patients with co-morbidity)

Study design

• Observational research study designs or standard of care arm from a trial

• Studies that statistically examined factors associated with subjective or psychological wellbeing or any of its dimensions using regression techniques

• Studies that statistically examined factors associated with mental health (i.e. mental illness- depression, anxiety) using regression techniques

• Letters, opinion pieces, editorials, reviews, qualitative studies

• Psychometric evaluations

• Studies were the sample size is n < 50

Outcomes

• Predictors of any dimension of subjective or psychological wellbeing or mental health

• Outcomes related to physical functioning

• Outcomes related to objective measures of quality of life (i.e. birth rate, school completion, mortality)

Other

• Peer-reviewed journal articles and non-published studies (conference abstracts, dissertations, working papers)

• English and non-English studies

• Studies conducted between January 2000–May 2019

 

Qualitative studies

Sample

• Young people living with HIV (aged 15–24 years)

• Caregivers of young people aged 15–24 years, healthcare workers, educators, other family members

• Studies that focus on specific population groups (i.e. orphans, LGBTQI, pregnant or post-partum women, sex workers, homeless youth, patients with co-morbidity)

Phenomenon of interest

• Subjective and psychological wellbeing, mental health

• Studies examining objective measures of quality of life

Design

• Studies incorporating any form of qualitative study design, data collection method or analytical technique

• Cross-sectional or longitudinal

• Studies with YPLHIV in the intervention arm of a trial

• Reviews, editorials, letters, essays, theoretical and opinion papers

• Studies evaluating a specific policy, programme or intervention

Evaluation

• Studies aimed at understanding the lived experiences of wellbeing or experiences related to any dimension of wellbeing or mental health

• Narrow focus on physical functioning, ART adherence, disclosure challenges, sexual reproductive health needs

Research type

• Qualitative or mixed-methods

• Quantitative studies

Other

• Peer-reviewed journal articles and non-published studies (conference abstracts, dissertations, working papers)

• English and non-English studies

• Studies conducted between January 2000–May 2019

Â