From: Systematic review of health-related quality of life models
Model used [Reference] | Authors [Reference] Country | Purpose | Design | Sample | Model guided or derived |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Wilson &; Cleary [12] | Baker, Pankhurst, &; Robinson [25] United Kingdom | To test Wilson and Cleary’s conceptual model of the direct and mediated pathways between clinical and non-clinical variables in relation to oral health-related quality of life (OHRQOL). | Randomized Controlled Trial | 85 patients with xerostomia attending outpatient clinics | Guided |
Wilson &; Cleary [12] | Cosby, Holzemer, Henry, &; Portillo [28] United States | To determine relationships among anemia, neutropenia, and thrombocytopenia and the five dimensions of the Wilson and Cleary model of HRQOL. | Correlational | 146 hospitalized patients with AIDS | Guided |
Wilson &; Cleary [12] | Frank, Auslander, &; Weissgarten [29] Israel | To examine quality of life among patients undergoing different types of treatment for end-stage renal disease at different points of the disease. | Descriptive | 72 patients with end-stage renal disease | Guided |
Wilson &; Cleary [12] | Hofer, Benzer, Alber, Ruttmann, Kopp, Schussler, et al. [30] Austria, Ireland, Germany | To apply the Wilson and Cleary model a priori to patients with coronary artery disease. | Correlational | 465 patients with coronary artery disease | Guided |
Wilson &; Cleary [12] | Janz, Janevic, Dodge, Fingerlin, Schork, Mosca, et al., [31] United States | To describe the impact of clinical and psychosocial factors on the quality of life of older women with heart disease. | Descriptive | 570 older women with heart disease | Guided |
Wilson &; Cleary [12] | Krethong, Jirapaet, Jitpanya, &; Sloan [32] Thailand | To examine causal relationships among bio-physiological status, symptoms, functional status, general health perception, HRQOL, and social support. | Correlational | 422 Thai patients with heart failure | Guided |
Wilson &; Cleary [12] | Mathias, Gao, Miller, Cella, Snyder, Turner, et al. [27] United States | To develop a conceptual model to describe the impact of immune thrombocytopenic purpura on HRQOL. | Qualitative &; Literature Review | 23 patients with immune thrombocytopenic purpura | Guided Derived |
Wilson &; Cleary [12] | Mathisen, Andersen, Veenstra, Wahl, Hanestad, &; Fosse [33] Norway | To determine whether reciprocal relationships existed between quality of life and health appraisal in those with coronary artery bypass surgery. | Correlational | 120 patients with coronary artery bypass surgery | Guided Derived |
Wilson &; Cleary [12] | Orfila, Ferrer, Lamarca, Tebe, Domingo-Salvany, &; Alonso [34] Spain | To determine whether gender differences in HRQOL among the elderly are explained by differences in performance-based functional capacity and chronic conditions. | Descriptive | 544 elderly persons | Guided Derived |
Wilson &; Cleary [12] | Penckofer Ferrans, Fink, Barrett, &; Holm [23] United States | To determine effect of coronary artery bypass Graft (CABG) surgery on quality of life of women. | Descriptive | 61 women with coronary artery bypass Surgery | Guided |
Wilson &; Cleary [12] | Sousa [35] United States | To describe a HRQOL model to guide clinical practice. | Literature Review | NA | Guided |
Wilson &; Cleary [12] | Sousa &; Kwok [24] United States | To validate Wilson &; Cleary’s model using structural equation modeling in HIV+ patients. | Correlational | 917 HIV+ patients | Guided |
Wilson &; Cleary [12] | Vidrine, Amick, Gritz, &; Arduino [36] Israel | To empirically assess a proximal-distal framework for conceptualizing HRQOL in individuals living with HIV/AIDS. An integrated model based on Wilson and Cleary (2005) was used. | Correlational | 348 people with HIV/AIDS | Guided Derived |
Wilson &; Cleary [12] | Wettergren, Bjorkholm, Axdorph, &; Langius-Eklof, [26] Sweden | To examine determinants of HRQOL in long-term survivors of Hodgkin’s Disease. | Mixed Methods | 121 long-term Hodgkin’s lymphoma survivors + 236 healthy controls | Guided |
Ferrans et al. [13] | Daggett, Bakas, &; Habermann [37] United States | To identify gaps in current knowledge of HRQOL and traumatic brain injury and apply findings to developing recommendations for future research with combat veterans with traumatic brain injury. | Literature Review | N/A | Guided |
Ferrans &; Powers [19] | Hill, Aldag, Hekel, Riner, &; Bloomfield [38] United States | To develop and test psychometric properties of a maternal post-partum quality of life measure. | Instrument Development | 184 post partum mothers | Guided |
Ferrans &; Powers [19] | Petchprapai &; Winkelman [39] Thailand United States | To analyze the literature related to the clinical, theoretical, and empirical determinates of mild traumatic brain injury. | Literature Review | N/A | Guided |
World Health Organization [20] | Fischer, LaRocca, Miller, Ritvo, Andrews, &; Paty [40] Canada &; United States | To (1) review recent efforts to assess the broader impact of MS on quality of life; (2) describe the development of the MS Quality of Life Inventory (MSQLI); (3) discuss issues to consider in selecting an MS quality of life instrument. | Instrument Development | 15 MS patients in pilot test, 300 MS patients in field test | Guided |
World Health Organization [21] | Hays, Hahn, &; Marshall [41] United States | To examine different conceptual models of HRQOL and examine implications of these perspectives for measurement of HRQOL in persons with disabilities. | Literature Review | N/A | Guided |
World Health Organization [20] | John [15] Germany | To explore the dimensional structure of OHRQOL using experts’ opinions using a conceptual model of oral health. | Instrument Development | 10 dentists &; 4 psychologists | Guided |
World Health Organization [20] | Post, deWitte, &; Schrijvers [42] Netherlands | To extend the World Health Organization international classification of impairments, disabilities, and handicaps in rehabilitation. | Literature Review | N/A | Guided Derived |
Ferrans, Zerwic, Wilbur, &; Larson [13] United States | To revise the Wilson and Cleary model of HRQOL. | Model Revision | N/A | Guided Derived | |
Valderas &; Alonso [22] United Kingdom Spain | To develop a classification system for patient-reported outcome measures based on Wilson &; Cleary’s HRQOL conceptual model and the World Health Organization International Classification of Functioning. | Literature Review | NA | Guided Derived |